First, another
dissenting view of Live 8.
The late Allan Bloom, in his
The Closing of the American Mind, faulted contemporary pop/rock music concerts for luring audiences into what he called "the illusion of shared emotion," that heady sentimentality that permeates, say, a U2 show. What's illusory is not the emotion - music is emotional, even if it's sappy, self-righteous blather - but the feeling that it has meaning, a feeling that makes cause-rock events like Live 8 unbearable. Which brings me to the point of today's worthless post:
Rock sucks.
This is not to say there are no good rock and roll bands. I've seen them. I know they exist. But the bands that dominate the charts and video channels and bloated self-congratulatory festivals are not them. Most of the "rock" vomited up by pretty-boys with big label contracts is self-absorbed, self-centered, solipsistic, narcissistic [insert your own redundancy here] whiney bullshit that makes Motley Crue look like classic rock.
I turned 12 the year Reagan took office, and I'll be honest, I feel a little gypped. Yeah, the 70's had its overstuffed prog-rock titans (ELO, Yes), gooey pretty-boy bands (The Bay City Rollers), and disco, but at least the idea of Rock as a party was still in effect. In the 80's the party was surrendered to hair metal, and everything else was lame pop and whiney gay men from England's industrial towns. Like most teenagers in the 80's, I was sucked in. I even saw The Smiths. Twice.
The 90's were not much better. Say what you want about Nirvana reviving the genre, but we have Kurt Cobain to thank for all the tortured-artist posturing we've had to endure for the last 15 years, and in the end even he couldn't take it. This decade hasn't produced much that's very promising (with the exception, perhaps, of bands like
Kings of Leon), unless some of the non-major-label acts I've seen can save the day (
Rev. Peyton's Big Damn Band,
Bad Wizard,
Broken Teeth...).
But I don't think it's going to happen, not soon. The culture has changed since 1980 in ways I've only been able to get my mind around in recent years (since I was just a polyester-wearing, pre-pubescent twit in the 70's). Anything and everything that seems a challenge to the status-quo is quickly absorbed by the market and sold as just another fashion statement. Rebellion is no longer something you do - it's something you
listen to, something you
wear, something you buy.
If you were hoping for a punchline, I'm sorry, I don't have one. Live 8 only serves to remind me what a corporate-driven culture we currently wallow in. Fuck Bob Geldof and his Rock and Roll fantasy.